This frustration with projection UI led me to the following medium comparison. This really came down to the benefits of projection being the communal aspect being a core benefit, the web being accessible to more people and more convenient and the AR being able to visualise the concept literally the best.
Photograph of medium comparison • David Valente
Will introduced the idea of presenting this clock in mobile AR. This is a medium I’m unfamiliar with but an a huge proponent for. I began the development for this medium with the following breakdown.
User needs, User goals, Constraints, Assumptions for AR:
Photograph of whiteboarding technique • David Valente
Understanding that AR is a hugely immersive experience compared to the traditional web/app model— I wanted embrace this as much as possible with the first mockup. Mimicking Snapchats minimal icon based UI atop of a camera view filled viewport, done in attempt to keep the features discoverable while unobtrusive to the naturally immersive AR experiance. This is a very crude idea thats been proven not to work, however this allowed the AR portion to take centre stage.
AR UI Mockup 1 • David Valente
Here is a video Will made of the implementation at this stage.
Below is my second attempt to design for this medium. I wanted to challenge the notions that the experience should remain the the immersive AR view. I did by providing a portrait view with the user options visible, constraining the fullscreen AR view to landscape. One of the driving forces for me dong this, is to allow a familiar, proven method to present text on a phone, rather than struggling to present text in the AR UI. During a critique in class, there was a general consensus that the experience should remain in a single AR view throughout.
AR UI Mockup 2 • David Valente
Later this day I came across this exhibition piece being prepared.
Photograph of projected interface at LCC • David Valente
Above is an exhibition piece in LCC from another student, that, once again highlights the low information density that this medium is forced into.
